The Smell of Success

Article Title: An Electrophilic Natural Product Provides a Safe and Robust Odor Neutralization Approach To Counteract Malodorous Organosulfur Metabolites Encountered in Skunk Spray
Authors: Lin Du, Charissa Munteanu, Jarrod B. King, Doug E. Frantz, Robert H. Cichewicz*
Journal: Journal of Natural Products
Year: 2019

Skunks are easily identified by the white stripes on their black body, but you’ll likely smell one before you see it. Although they are nocturnal animals that prefer their own company, skunks won’t hesitate to spray potential predators, people or pets with fluid from their anal glands.

For many years, these anal secretions have fascinated natural products chemists but repelled most of the rest of us because they contain a pungent mix of thiols (the sulfur version of alcohols).

Unfortunately, these oily, smelly substances easily cling to clothing, hair, skin and fur so complete odor removal – aka “de-skunking” – is challenging, especially considering how well the human nose can detect low concentrations of thiols. In fact, if you want to know how well your lab hood works, open some essence of skunk inside of it.

Home remedies and store-bought items that claim to eliminate skunk odors often suffer from limited success or contain eye and skin irritants. In fact, a research team, led by Professor Robert Cichewisz of the University of Oklahoma, used LC-MS to show that 5 of 6 commercially-available de-skunking products did not chemically alter model compound 2-phenylethanethiol, one of many smelly thiols present in skunk spray.

Instead, Cichewisz thought a natural product-based alternative could be a better solution. The researchers previously isolated a molecule known as pericosine A from the fungi Tolypocladium. They knew pericosine A could protect fungi against antibiotics and toxics that are nucleophilic, which are molecules that have a tendency to donate electrons to other molecules or react at electron-poor areas of a compound. The researchers hypothesized that this electrophilic natural product, which has a tendency to attract or acquire electrons, and its synthetic analogues could react with nucleophilic thiols found in skunk spray to yield odorless products that could easily be removed from affected surfaces.

Figure 1: A photo of Tolypocladium fungi that produces pericosin A. (Photo credit: Used with permission from Professor Robert Cichewisz.)

The authors reacted pericosine A with compounds 1 and 2, which are similar to those found in skunk spray, and determined that pericosine A reacted with thiols and thioesters under basic conditions. In fact, catalytic base Et3N could be used to significantly increase the rate of reaction, and the product distribution was also dependent upon the amounts of starting materials and reagents used.

Figure 2: (A) chemical structures of the major thiols in skunk secretions. (B) Past and present solutions to “de-skunking”. Reprinted with permission from Du, L.; Munteanu, C.; King, J. B.; Frantz, D. E.; Cichewicz, R. H. J. Nat. Prod. 2019, 82 (7), 1989-1999. Copyright 2019 American Chemical Society.

After showing that pericosine A and structurally similar compounds could successfully eliminate thiol odors, the researchers substituted some of the original reagents with new components thought to be safer for topical applications. For example, the Et3N base was replaced with the naturally occurring base spermine, a component of eukaryotic cells that’s already incorporated into some existing cosmetic products.

With optimized conditions established, the researchers then reacted sulfur-containing compounds harvested from skunk secretions with pericosine A and its analogues. The research team smelt success – literally – as the smell from thiols in the skunk spray became much less pronounced throughout the lab. Analytical methods confirmed the formation of new, odorless products. Lastly, the researchers established that pericosine A was not toxic or irritating toward skin and eye tissues, opening the door for future research.

As a whole, this paper presents a straightforward, natural products-based approach to odor neutralization of sulfur-containing compounds. The researchers anticipate commercial applications for pericosine A and its analogues in the future.

Leave a Reply